Chicago Sports & Travel, Inc./AllsportsAmerica
"America's Finest Sports Fan Travel Club, May We Plan An Event Or Sports Travel For You?"
Sports Quote of the Day:
"Every accomplishment starts with the decision to try." ~ Gail Devers, Three Time Olympic Gold Medalist
Chicago Sports & Travel, Inc./AllsportsAmerica Opinion: The Bears have a bye this week. Anything is possible but very improbable. We hate to be the bearers of bad news and say, "The Bears season is over," however, We truly don't see the Bears in this year's NFL's playoff picture. We always advocate for Chicago's sports teams and try to remain the eternal optimist and this is no exception. We hope and pray that our Bears can turn the ship around. It's never too late and again, anything is possible. Below are two articles with different sports writers thoughts on our beloved Bears. Read them and if you so desire, go to the comments section at the bottom of the blog and express your views. We'd love to know how you feel!!!
Bear Down Chicago Bears!!! Analysts: Bears' problems are more than just Jay Cutler.
By Rich Campbell
Patriots tight end Rob Gronkowski gets up after a reception against Bears linebacker Shea McClellin in the second quarter. (Brian Cassella / Chicago Tribune)
Quarterback Jay Cutler’s inconsistency protecting the ball is a major reason why the Chicago Bears are a disappointing 3-5. But their list of problems is much longer than that, as Sunday’s 51-23 loss to the New England Patriots reminded us.
“Jay gets a lot of criticism, and that comes with the territory,” said Louis Riddick, former director of pro personnel for the Philadelphia Eagles and Washington Redskins and current ESPN analyst. “But as I much as I respect (general manager) Phil Emery, they’re just flawed in their construction. The people there, if they’re honest about it, they know that they are.”
Emery and coach Marc Trestman have acknowledged deficiencies in all three phases. Whether it be poor linebacker play or punt coverage, the issues amount to more than Cutler can overcome playing at his current level.
Riddick shared his thoughts about them in a recent phone interview, and former Pittsburgh Steelers coach Bill Cowher offered his perspective Tuesday on a teleconference involving several Thursday Night Football analysts from CBS and NFL Network.
“With Jay, they want him to be…the deodorant for everything else that’s wrong, and he’s just not,” Riddick said. “That’s what falls back on you as a team builder. You’ve got to make it all smell better by your ability to build it right and the coaches’ ability to adapt and make up the difference.
"It’ll be a total organizational collapse if it doesn’t turn out, and if they pull out of it, it’s going to because everyone pulls their weight.”
Cowher’s first focus was a defense the Patriots left in ruins. Yes, the unit has improved in several categories. Its yards allowed per play is down from a league-worst 6.2 in 2013 to 6.0 (25th in NFL) through eight games. But those strides seemed more insignificant with each touchdown the Patriots scored.
“That wasn’t Jay Cutler playing defense,” Cowher said. “That wasn’t him trying to cover a tackle and do those things. I still think he’s a good quarterback. I think he does have leadership -- it's not one of his strong suits. But at the same time, you can win with him, but he needs to have a better defense around him that gives that team a chance. They can’t rely on him not to keep throwing the ball like he does because he does get careless at times.”
Riddick was sharper and more specific with his critique.
“It’s easy to say, well, the reason why in Chicago we won’t win any Super Bowls is because of Jay Cutler,” he said. “That’s not true, either. Their defense is horrific. They’re not going to win any Super Bowls with that defense. I can tell you that.
“The defense is weak right down the middle. (Tackle Jeremiah) Ratliff is starting to look like the guy who they hoped he would be when they acquired him. They still don’t have the kind of production out of Will Sutton and Ego Ferguson that they need. They have no one, really, in the middle of the defense at the linebacker position as far as their production and/or from a leadership perspective, which is why Brandon Marshall now is the spokesman of the football team and none of the signal callers are -- the quarterback is not, the linebacker is not.
“(Safety) Ryan Mundy is an average football player. (Safety) Chris Conte is guy who they’ve been trying to replace, and Brock Vereen is just a young rookie. They’re kind of flawed from a composition perspective when you’re looking at leadership at those crucial signal-caller positions, and they’re deficient as far as their skill sets. So, yes, they have some nice individual pieces on the perimeter; football teams are built inside-out, down the middle. That’s where they’re flawed, defensively in particular.”
Riddick and Cowher each see deficiencies in the offensive line, which has suffered from injuries to four out of five starters since the regular season began.
“They keep talking about this great offensive line; I don’t think it’s a good offensive line,” Cowher said. “I mean, when you have to sit there and protect your tackle, and you’re playing at home, and you have to put two tight ends against the edges and you’re talking about an offense that throws the ball vertically down the field, so you’re holding the ball longer.
“They’re really kind of unconventional in today’s passing game. They don’t use a lot of screens. They got rid of Devin Hester, who gave them a little element of that. They’re a vertical passing team that doesn’t have a great offensive line, so (Cutler) is not holding the ball quickly. So at times, when he does have time, and people can’t generate a rush, the guy’s accurate. But he gets banged around a little bit. He gets rattled. I think they have some offensive line issues on offense.”
Besides the personnel around Cutler, Riddick’s and Cowher’s comments made it clear that at the national level, Cutler continues to fight perceptions about his leadership no matter how much Emery and Trestman praise his work ethic and investment in the organization.
Riddick questions the quality of Cutler’s situation play, and “that becomes even more magnified because when you watch him get up there during press conferences during the week or immediately following a game, you just want more,” he said.
Said Cowher: “I think he’s a good quarterback but a poor leader. And I think that’s the thing at times a quarterback, though -- at times -- may not have to be the greatest quarterback, but they need to be the leader and take control when the bullets start to fly. And sometimes I feel like when the bullets are starting to fly around Jay, he’s not at his best. And at times I think he’s a detriment; just his body language, his inability at times to take the moment and seize it and be a leader.
"All the great quarterbacks, and you watch them, it’s when the bullets start to fly, they take control of the situation, and that football team (Chicago) isn’t going to go where Jay goes.”
All of those issues are why Riddick, with his personnel background, considers Emery's evaluation of Cutler as most critical to the Bears' future.
"This is where your team-building chops are really put to the test as a general manager because what are you going to do?" Riddick said. "You’re in purgatory. Cutler is not a franchise guy that’s going to lift everyone else. So how can you build it around him to kind of lift him so he can take you where you want to go? If you don’t want to look at it that way, you’re going to constantly have this kind of narrative surrounding your football team."
'Balance' remarks point to possible change in Bears offensive mindset.
By John Mullin
Chicago Bears Head Coach Marc Trestman (L) and General Manager Phil Emery (R)
Whether it is too late or not remains to play out over the next nine weeks or so. But in perhaps one of the few positives emerging from the disastrous first half of this season and from Monday’s comments by general manager Phil Emery and head coach Marc Trestman gave indications of learning a lesson that Mike Martz, among others, never quite grasped.
The “lesson” was balance, reaching an equilibrium on offense that made use of the run as both an end in itself and as an adjunct to slowing pass rushes and protecting a quarterback. And part of the lesson involves knowing what Jay Cutler is. And isn’t.
Emery cited “the lack of consistency and working together to get it done in terms of being error-free and continuing to stay on time, so you can build a balance of what you're doing run-pass.”
Trestman added: “And I’ve got to do a better job of that. I do have to do a better job with that and that comes with our first-down productivity has to be better. We have to get it where it was the year ago where we’re in continuity with the chains and we’re in second-and-manageable situations and so forth.”
“Balance” is never a goal, more an objective, a means to achieving the real goal – winning – but Trestman has appeared to some to have scant interest in that approach.
With some justification. The Bears were not especially run-pass balanced vs. the 49ers and Jets, yet won both games by eight points. And they ran 41 times vs. 37 pass plays in being crushed by the Green Bay Packers in the next game.
But one impression from Monday’s remarks by Trestman and Emery was that they have an increasing understanding of Cutler.
He is not a quarterback who can consistently win games with his arm, if only because he does not have ball security as his ultimate default setting. A recurrent theme from too many opposing defensive players is that the NFL knows that if Cutler is forced to settle for check-downs or work underneath, eventually he will make a game-altering mistake, either interception or fumble.
The Dallas “model”
The Dallas Cowboys came to a similar realization this season when a chronically underachieving offense tilted away from Tony Romo’s arm and toward a balance based on DeMarco Murray’s legs and not just Romo’s passing, which could too often be counted on to provide critical turnovers.
This year has been different, in multiple ways:
Year | Run:Pass % | Record
2011 | 40:60 | 8-8
2012 | 40:60 | 8-8
2013 | 35:65 | 8-8
2014 | 50:50 | 6-2
The Cowboys were 51-percent run before Monday, when they rushed 25 times (for 166 yards) vs. 39 pass plays, even with Romo missing part of the second half with a back injury. Romo was sacked five times and the Cowboys lost in overtime.
“You have to continue to keep a balance of sorts, understanding that you may not gain a lot of yards per carry,” offensive coordinator Aaron Kromer said. “But if you just drop back and pass it the whole game, they will get active and hit your quarterback.”
A suspect underlying mindset
The Bears have trailed by 10 or more at halftime in four of their eight games. They lost three of them.
“We gotta get ourselves in a position, score-wise, where we can [balance] from the get-go, and part of that is starting faster,” Emery said. “When you’re playing Miami and you’re down 14-0 at home, you’re going to have to pass the football.”
Actually, no.
While conventional wisdom – and Bears thinking – is that getting down by a couple scores means needing to throw to catch up, two things are wrong with that: One, the Bears are built to theoretically be able to out-score opponents (they scored 21 in the fourth quarter to defeat San Francisco) by either air or land; and two, Cutler’s turnover tendencies make putting the comeback solely on his arm a suspect strategy.
It worked in San Francisco, and it worked last year in Cleveland, where Cutler engineered the comeback that stamped him as “franchise” in Emery’s thinking. But Cutler is not Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Aaron Rodgers or other elite passers who are so ball-secure in their passing.
The Bears have enough in Matt Forte (with help from Ka’Deem Carey) that they do not need to continue relying on a quarterback whose tendencies have not, by Emery’s own assessment, fundamentally changed from his days at Vanderbilt, through Denver and through five-and-a-half seasons in Chicago.